by kitaj on Tue May 04, 2021 6:26 am
Thanks again, David J.
Your interpretation of several passages of the song's lyrics are insightful, and also interesting because I have for myself come to think this song actually marked a dent in the overall positivity of the love intoxication narrated throughout Dead Bees - a thematically darkened moment that had kind of begun with 'Darkest Dreaming' and was to go on, documenting and deepening this newfound divide all the way up to 'Before and Afterlife'; but at this stage, it reads like a new restlessness ("gaining the world", "leaving America", "ambush the world") after the blissful loving seclusion that had lasted the years before. The driving pace of the Allen/Morton version bears this restlessness out - the protagonist in motion and unrest, travelling, both literally and internally, again. Also, I somehow didn't think the "girl" was Ingrid - more Ameera, maybe? Like, a greater empathy establishing itself between father and child than the one between the child's mother and her soon-to-be-estranged husband. (And yes, I too wonder about its exclusion from 'Hypergraphia'.) I think he may have rewritten the lyrics for the new 'Scent of Magnolia' version - the old title, '100 Years', doesn't ring any bell to these new lyrics for me.
By the way, how did you all fellow fans take to the extended version of Dead Bees in the end? I haven't bought the vinyl, but I've not been able to get used to the new track order in the mirroring playlist I made myself listen to, so I came up with a personally more satisfying one, wherein among other track order changes I put 'Magnolia' between 'Dobro #1' and 'Midnight Sun', which works a charm for me also considering my above interpretation of the song's narrative. However, I didn't think the Allen/Morton version fits in that well with the whole album stylistically - it really feels like a late addendum to the collection, thus I prefer to consider it more of a shoulda-been single/12" standalone version; so I put the 'Portobello mix' in its place to be the 'album version' - which one, by the way, bears out the Indian sonic influence much more in Steve's percussion timbres and patterns, thus linking it both with 'Krishna Blue' and even 'Brilliant Trees', I'm happy to say.
Last edited by
kitaj on Sat May 08, 2021 5:16 am, edited 1 time in total.